Click HERE for the list of other Very Important Mariners Of 2017.
On first glance, it feels like this name should be higher on the list, but when you consider he’s the first position player after the Big Three, it feels a little more appropriate.
For what it’s worth, I feel like we’re in good hands with Cano, Cruz, and Seager. It would be pretty crippling if one or more of those guys got significantly injured or otherwise underperformed in 2017, but if I had to put money on it, I’d say we’ll be okay with those guys. It’s with Segura – and some of our other new guys brought in to bring even more stability to this offense – that I start to really worry.
Last year, I’d say the Mariners’ offense was slightly above average. It was good enough to get the job done, had the pitching also been up to the task. With great pitching, last year’s team could have been a World Series contender, but that’s neither here nor there. This year’s offense I’m projecting to be even better! We just need the pitching to not fall apart and we should remain in contention for the full season; halfway decent pitching should be enough to get us over the hump.
I feel that way because with the addition of Segura – who we received in trade for Taijuan Walker – it looks like our Big Three has morphed into a Big Four. Obviously, there are other additions to this team that I’m factoring into my overall opinion, but Segura is the biggest piece; hence why I’m so worried.
Segura has had four full seasons in the Major Leagues, but he only has the one great one. Granted, for a change, his great season was last year – which makes him one of the few incoming players we’re NOT trying to bank on a bounceback performance – but still, the fact that we traded one of our biggest assets to get him is a real gamble on our part!
He hit 20 homers last year; his previous high was 12 (he also had seasons with 5 and 6 homers). He hit 41 doubles last year; his previous high was 20 (with seasons of 14 and 16). His slash line last year was .319/.368/.499/.867; his previous best season was in 2013 when he slashed .294/.329/.423/.752 (with his 2014 and 2015 seasons being pretty unremarkable in this department as well). Now, if you sat me down and GUARANTEED me we’d get his exact 2013 production (with the aforementioned 20 doubles and 12 homers), or we could roll the dice to see if he could replicate his breakout season of 2016 (or, God forbid, actually improve upon it), I think I would shake your hand and take those 2013 numbers all day every day. Because those numbers are LEAPS AND BOUNDS better than what we got out of Ketel Marte (who also went over to Arizona in this trade), and most other short stops we’ve had around here, since the A-Rod days. However, my concern is – due to the perceived Seattle Mariners curse – he reverts even further and gives us those crappy numbers from 2014 or 2015. It would be just so Mariners to give up two young, cheap, cost-controlled potential superstars for a guy who had one great season and then went right back to being a pumpkin.
I know they’re different circumstances, and different players, but I’m catching a big Adrian Beltre vibe off of this move. Recall Beltre had the best season of his career the year before the Mariners signed him to a huge deal; then he reverted right back to his old numbers or worse. Sure, his Hall of Fame defense made up for a lot of that – and if Segura gives us that type of defense (which, signs point to Probably Not), then fine – but it was still a case of a team paying for recent past performance and getting bit in the ass.
All that having been said, there are some encouraging parts to this thing. Like I got into a little bit above, I think regardless of what we get, it’s a step up from Ketel Marte. Marte is a fringe guy right now and might never develop into anything. If he does, he’s probably a couple-two-three years away from being a bona fide regular MLB player. For a team like the 2017 Mariners, in obvious Win-Now Mode, you can’t waste your time spinning your wheels trying to develop someone like Marte, who – for all the good he has in him – makes too many mental and physical mistakes to be a net positive. With Segura, you’ve got a productive, veteran guy you can slot somewhere in the top of your order. He’s also a guy I’m pretty confident can get on base at a good clip, which slides right into my next plus: he’s speedy. 122 stolen bases the last four years. With some of the speedy outfield guys we’ve got that can slot next to him in the lineup, it’s pretty alluring with the likes of Cano, Cruz, and Seager lined up behind them. Segura, if nothing else, should score around or over 100 runs if nothing else, so long as he stays healthy.
And, hey, not to dump on Marte too much, but Segura’s defense should be good enough that he doesn’t give you a lot of the boneheaded throws and whatnot.
I’m not sold on Segura until I see him in some regular season action, but I’m better-than-50% confident he’ll be a quality player for this team, and I think that really bodes well for the offense and this team’s overall chances.