Originally Published: May 28, 2013
The Seattle Mariners played their first season in 1977. From 1977 through 1994, the Mariners were varying degrees of terrible.
Sometimes Two times, “terrible” came with a winning record (1991 & 1993), but no post-season appearance. Then, in 1995, the Mariners broke on through with an AL West title and a legend was made. People still talk about those 1995 Mariners in a reverential tone and for good reason. Baseball fans in the northwest starving for the sweet taste of success finally had something to hang their hats on.
From 1995 through 2003, the Mariners were varying degrees of successful. Those nine seasons saw the Mariners make the playoffs four times, winning three division titles. Seven of those nine seasons saw the Mariners with winning records. Two insanely good A’s teams prevented two 93-win Mariners teams from going to the playoffs four straight years from 2000-2003. These were the good times. Everything abruptly fell apart in 2004 and the team was blown up.
From 2004 through present day, the Mariners have returned to their varying degrees of terrible. In the nine full seasons from 2004-2012, the Mariners have had a winning record twice. They’ve finished last in the AL West seven times. It’s been one rebuild after another, with no end in sight. Just a continuation of the cycle of losing, ad infinitum.
Of course, if the Mariners could do it once, SURELY the Mariners can do it again. It took until their 19th year of existence before the Mariners made the playoffs; if it feels hopeless now, just imagine what it must have felt like for Mariners fans in the early 1990s. They say something about learning from history or being doomed to repeat it, but what if in this case we take a look at something that went RIGHT for the Mariners in their history and seeing if we can repeat THAT?
As fans, we have to believe that a turnaround is right around the corner. I know I’m on here quite a bit, bitching about how nothing is ever going to get any better (because why would we think that? What is trending well enough for us to deserve the luxury of hope?), but if I truly felt that way, why would I continue to follow this team? I’m not a baseball fan, per se; I’m a Mariners fan. I don’t sit around watching random baseball games in my spare time; I watch Mariners games. If the Mariners moved to Oklahoma City, I would stop watching baseball, the same as I have stopped watching professional basketball. If the Mariners had never existed, I never would have started watching baseball in the first place (you get the idea). So, since it’s been established that I’m a Mariners fan, it should also be established that yes, I do hope they’re able to turn things around sooner rather than later. I’m not 100% cynical. I’m just beaten down and broken, but all that can change if a few things fucking broke right for the Mariners for once!
The one thing Jackie Z has done right in his tenure as general manager is: he’s re-stocked the farm system with an abundance of talented prospects. Of course, none of that talent (save Kyle Seager and a couple bullpen arms) has panned out at the Major League level, but there’s more than one way to skin a cat.
There is no “right way” to rebuild. It’s a combination of youth and veterans. It’s a combination of draft picks, trades, and free agent signings. It’s a combination of luck, strategy, and luck again. In an ideal world, your Major League roster would be riddled with your own draft picks still playing on rookie deals. Every trade you made would work out splendidly for you and would tank for your trade partner. Every free agent signing would be a “buy-low” situation where they immediately turned their careers around.
Or, if you like concrete examples: every draft pick would be Ken Griffey Jr., every trade would net you Jay Buhner in return, and every free agent would be Bret Boone circa 2000/2001.
So, in an attempt to try and forget the miseries of our present-day situation, I’d like to go back to a simpler time where a team comprised of a mix of youth and veterans shocked the world by winning their very first division title in the most dramatic of fashions. How was THAT team built? What can we learn from how that team did what it did? And how did that team evolve into the greatest regular season team in baseball history?
1995 Seattle Mariners
Rebuilds don’t happen overnight. A lot of these guys were brought into the fold well before everything magically came together in 1995. I’m not going to get into every single player, but I’ll go over the highlights.
Dan Wilson (catcher) was drafted by the Cincinnati Reds in 1990 in the first round. That was the same year Lou Pinella signed on to manage those very same Reds. That was also the same year the Reds won the World Series and wrote Lou’s ticket as an elite baseball manager for the next couple decades. Sweet Lou hitched his wagon to the Seattle Mariners in 1993 with the task of turning around the worst franchise in baseball. Dan Wilson got his first taste of the majors in a September cup of coffee in 1992. Wilson got some more playing time in 1993, but was then traded along with Bobby Ayala to be reunited with Pinella before the 1994 season. Wilson played considerably in ’94, earned the starting job in ’95, and never looked back.
Tino Martinez (first base) was drafted by the Seattle Mariners in 1988 in the first round. He received his cup of coffee in 1990 and didn’t play a whole lot in the Majors through 1991. Martinez was mediocre (but played a lot more) from 1992-1994, then finally had his breakout season in 1995 (.293/.369/.551).
Joey Cora (second base) was drafted by the San Diego Padres in 1985 in the first round. Cora didn’t start earning regular playing time until after he’d been traded to the White Sox in 1991. His numbers weren’t particularly impressive, but he was improving as he played regularly through the 1994 season. Then, in April of 1995, Cora signed as a free agent with the Mariners. In spite of what we choose to remember about Little Joey Cora, I think many of us forget just how productive he was as a Mariner. From 1995 through August of 1998, Cora had a slash line of .293/.355/.406. He was traded at the August trade deadline in 1998, then abruptly retired to go into coaching after the end of the season.
Mike Blowers (third base) was originally drafted by the Seattle Mariners in 1984 but did not sign. He would go on to be drafted three more times before he finally signed with the Montreal Expos in 1986. He would be traded to the Yankees in August of 1989, then traded to the Mariners in May of 1991. Blowers originally broke into the Majors with the Yankees in 1989, but he wouldn’t become a starter in the Majors until 1993 with the Mariners. He would go on to be traded by the Mariners after that historic 1995 season, but would later come back on one-year free agent deals in 1997 and again in 1999 before retiring after that 1999 season.
Ken Griffey Jr. (center field) was originally drafted by the Seattle Mariners with the #1 overall pick in the 1987 draft. He would become a starter in the 1989 season and would not look back. In February of 2000, the Mariners would trade him to the Reds. They brought him back as a free agent in February of 2009 before he retired in June of 2010.
Jay Buhner (right field) was drafted by the Pittsburgh Pirates in January of 1984. In December of that very same year, Buhner was traded to the Yankees. Buhner got his cup of coffee with the Yankees in September of 1987, played a bit more in 1988, then was traded at that year’s deadline to the Seattle Mariners for Ken Phelps. Buhner became an everyday player in 1991 and was a core piece of the Mariners’ offense for the next decade.
Edgar Martinez (designated hitter) signed as an amateur free agent with the Seattle Mariners in December of 1982. He didn’t break into the Majors until 1987 and didn’t become an everyday player until 1990. He would go on to become the greatest designated hitter in baseball history.
Randy Johnson (starting pitcher) was drafted by the Montreal Expos in 1985 in the second round. The Big Unit got his cup of coffee in September of 1988, making four starts. He was traded in May of 1989 to the Seattle Mariners for Mark Langston. He became an immediate starter for the Mariners and progressively got better until he broke out in 1993, coming in second in the AL Cy Young race. Johnson would go on to win that award in 1995, leading the Mariners to their best playoff finish in franchise history. He would go on to be dealt to the Astros at the 1998 trade deadline and never return.
I’ll spare you Tim Belcher‘s long history for the most part: he was drafted in 1984 and kicked around with four different teams before he signed with the Reds in May of 1995, where he was promptly traded to the Mariners two weeks later without ever throwing a pitch for the Reds that season. Belcher made 28 starts for the Mariners that season, going 10-12. He would not be retained by the Mariners beyond 1995.
Chris Bosio (starting pitcher) was drafted by the Milwaukee Brewers in 1982 in the second round. He had a good career with the Brewers over 7 seasons, then signed with the Seattle Mariners as a free agent in December of 1992. In 1993, Bosio pitched the second-ever Mariners no-hitter. In 1995, Bosio started 31 games and went 10-8. He hung around to start the 1996 season, struggled mightily, and retired at season’s end.
The Mariners traded for Andy Benes from the San Diego Padres at the July deadline in 1995. He would go on to make 12 starts down the stretch, going 7-2. He would sign a free agent deal with St. Louis before the 1996 season and would never be heard from again.
The bullpen was a piece of work, anchored by Bobby Ayala (came over in the Dan Wilson trade in 1993), who appeared in 63 games. Norm Charlton was originally traded by the Reds to the Mariners prior to the 1993 season, but he would be injured, lose all of the 1994 season to injury, and eventually sign with the Phillies in 1995. He was released by the Phillies in July of 1995 and signed on with the Mariners four days later. Jeff Nelson was originally drafted by the Dodgers in 1984, but then was drafted by the Mariners from the Dodgers in something called a “minor league draft” in 1986. He became a regular reliever in 1992 and was consistently productive thereafter.
That, more or less, is the 1995 Mariners. Obviously, there were lots of bench players and fill-ins (Rich Amaral & Alex Diaz filling in admirably for an injured Junior), and a lot of players who were tried out as starters in the rotation, but the players I listed comprised the core. Seven guys brought over in trade, three free agents, and four guys who were drafted by the Mariners (well, three guys and Edgar, who was an amateur free agent and played his entire career under the same organization).
1996 Seattle Mariners
With the base already in place, I shouldn’t have to keep re-hashing the core group that remains. The first big misstep in what would become a long line of soul-crushing missteps by the organization came on December 7, 1995, when the Mariners traded Tino Martinez and Jeff Nelson to the New York Yankees. In return, they received a starting third baseman in Russ Davis, and a starting pitcher in Sterling Hitchcock.
Davis was the most error-prone third baseman I’ve ever seen. He was supposed to make up for that with his bat, but in the four years he wore a Mariners uniform, he never surpassed 21 homers in a season, with a Mariners career slash line of .256/.309/.446. Tino Martinez would go on to have an outstanding career with the Yankees, hitting 175 homers and 180 doubles over the next six seasons. Jeff Nelson would go on to be a fabulous bullpen presence for the Yankees over the next five seasons, before returning as a free agent to the Mariners prior to the 2001 season. Sterling Hitchcock, meanwhile, lasted one season with the Mariners (1996) where he sucked. Then, he was traded to the Padres for Scott Sanders, who also sucked. Sanders lasted one season with the Mariners (1997) before being traded for two guys who did nothing. Suffice it to say, the Mariners lost the SHIT out of this trade.
All was not totally lost for this 1996 team, though. The Mariners signed Paul Sorrento (first base) as a free agent before the season started. Sorrento was an okay veteran who had played in 7 regular seasons with two different teams before coming to the Kingdome where he would mash the hell out of the ball for the 1996 and 1997 seasons. We let him go after 1997 and he signed with Tampa Bay where he would finish out his career.
Alex Rodriguez (short stop) was drafted with the #1 overall pick by the Seattle Mariners in 1993. He got his cup of coffee in 1994, and mostly rode the pine in 1995 before earning the everyday short stop job in 1996. He would put up MVP-type numbers in this season, yet be denied his rightful honor thanks to the idiots who voted for the MVP award that season (they picked Juan Gonzalez of the Rangers who had a markedly inferior season). A-Rod would be a Mariners favorite from 1996 through the 2000 season before taking the money and running to the Rangers in 2001.
Rich Amaral (left field) was signed as a free agent before the 1991 season before ever playing a game in the Majors. Amaral earned a lot of playing time in 1995 after Griffey went down with injury that cost him a majority of the season. As a reward for doing such a good job, Amaral earned the left field job in 1996. He would go on to stick around (mostly as a bench player) through the 1998 season before signing as a free agent with the Orioles and ending his career in Baltimore.
So, the ’96 lineup had new additions Sorrento & Davis with holdovers in Amaral, A-Rod, Wilson, Cora, Griffey, Buhner, and Edgar. Pretty fucking good … until you get to the pitching staff …
Hitchcock became the de facto pitching ace for this team after Randy Johnson went down in May with his back injury. He would return in August as a reliever and never started a game for the Mariners the rest of the season.
Bob Wolcott was a Mariners draft pick from 1992 in the second round. He made his first starts in the Majors in 1995 in August and earned himself a playoff roster spot that netted him the start in Game 1 of the ALCS (as the rotation had been spent just trying to get past the Yankees in five games of the ALDS). From that ALCS victory, Wolcott earned himself a rotation spot in 1996. He mostly underwhelmed. He played one more season in Seattle (1997) and was lost to the Arizona Diamondbacks in the expansion draft of 1997.
Jamie Moyer was drafted back in 1984 by the Chicago Cubs. He had played in 10 Major League seasons with five different teams (Cubs, Rangers, Cardinals, Orioles, Red Sox) before he was traded by the Red Sox to the Mariners at the 1996 deadline. Moyer would go on to play 11 years with the Mariners and end up one of the best pitchers in team history.
Terry Mulholland, on the other hand, would NOT go down as one of the best pitchers in team history. The 1996 Mariners were enjoying unprecedented offensive success, but injuries had throttled their pitching staff. Mulholland, like Moyer, was a veteran of a million other teams before he was traded to the Mariners at the 1996 deadline. He came in and did okay, but it would prove to be a fruitless endeavor as the Mariners – while above .500 – failed to make the playoffs. Mulholland would never pitch for the Mariners beyond this season.
The primary bullpen addition (with Charlton and Ayala leading the way for the most part) was Michael Jackson. He was another longtime vet who the Mariners brought in on a 1-year deal prior to the 1996 season. He had pitched with the Mariners early in the 90s and was a quality arm in the bullpen who locked down the 8th inning and didn’t get nearly enough save opportunities.
1997 Seattle Mariners
The batting lineup was almost exactly the same in 1997. Rich Amaral even enjoyed his usual 89 games of stellar fill-in duty. The only major change in this year was the tantalizing tease that was Jose Cruz Jr. He was drafted by the Mariners with the #3 overall pick in the 1995 draft and was brought up by the Mariners in 1997 to start in left field effective May 31st. In his 49 games, Cruz had 12 homers and 12 doubles. Along with Griffey and A-Rod, he was looking like another can’t-miss first round prospect who would go on to have a Hall of Fame type career.
Of course, this Mariners team couldn’t afford to live with their Pie in the Sky dreams of future glory; they had to strike NOW, while the iron was hot! This was a good baseball team, with another massively impressive offense, and little in the way of pitching (especially bullpen pitching).
So, at the trade deadline, the Mariners made the two trades that will forever be a black mark on this organization. On the same day, the Mariners sent Derek Lowe and Jason Varitek (two minor leaguers with incredible promise) to the Boston Red Sox for Heathcliff Slocumb. Slocumb was immediately inserted into the closer’s role because Norm Charlton had officially hit the wall in his career. The other trade was one Jose Cruz Jr., who was sent to the Toronto Blue Jays for Mike Timlin and Paul Spoljaric. Both of those two were inserted into the regular bullpen rotation. Timlin was okay, Spoljaric was a lefty and not that good. This mishmash of a bullpen, with a surprising resurgence by Bobby Ayala, managed to get the job done enough to get the Mariners into the playoffs, but it was a hefty price to pay that ultimately never did pay off in a World Series Championship as intended.
Lost in the shuffle of the 1997 season was actually one of the better trades in Mariners history. In October of 1996, the Mariners traded a bunch of scrubs to the Expos for Jeff Fassero. He fit in quite nicely with our rotation stalwarts of Randy Johnson (back and better than ever from his injury-plagued 1996 season) and Jamie Moyer. Fassero rounded out our Big Three for the 1997 & 1998 seasons before falling off the cliff in 1999 and being traded away to the Rangers.
The Mariners plugged in some draft picks (Lowe, pre-trade, and Ken Cloude) as well as some veterans (Dennis Martinez, signed as a free agent; and Omar Olivares, who was brought over when the team dealt Scott Sanders to the Tigers) into the back-end of their rotation, but no one really stuck. For this season or long-term.
1998 Seattle Mariners
The primary addition to the starting lineup was David Segui (first base) who was signed as a free agent. The team had let Paul Sorrento walk and needed some kind of production. Segui was a solid, if unspectacular contributor who had a nice year and a half with the Mariners before being traded at the 1999 deadline.
The 1998 Mariners continued their revolving door at left field, with no one of import taking the bull by the horns.
The ’98 Mariners had what amounted to a stable starting rotation, shock of shocks. After the Big Three, Ken Cloude was granted one of the final two spots. He was drafted by the Mariners in the sixth round in 1993 and made his first Major League start in 1997. He would start 30 games in 1998, but his ERA would be over 6 and he would go only 8-10. Cloude was primarily a bullpen pitcher, with a few spot starts here and there in 1999, then his career would be over.
Grabbing the final rotation spot was veteran Bill Swift. Swifty was drafted by the Mariners in the first round in 1984, but was traded away in 1991 and bounced around for a while before signing as a free agent in February of 1998. He would go 11-9 with a 5.85 ERA in 1998 and then he would retire.
The 1998 Mariners were the first team of this era to end the season with a losing record. I’ll be damned if I know how that’s possible with an offense this stacked, but let’s go ahead and start with Randy Johnson. This was a contract year for him and he was pretty much blowing it. He was 9-10 with a 4.33 ERA in his 23 starts before the trade deadline. The Mariners as an organization had balked at the notion of re-signing him to a long-term extension, citing the 1996 season and his back injury as a reason to be cautious. Tensions grew from there and by the trade deadline, the team knew it wasn’t going to be able to retain him beyond the season. They felt they had to trade him to get some kind of value back in return. So, he was dealt to the Astros (where he proceeded to dominate the shit out of the National League with a 10-1 record and a sub-2 ERA) for prospects.
One could also blame the 1998 misfortunes on the bullpen. They managed only 31 saves as a unit, with Bobby Ayala returning to his absolute nadir (a 1-10 record with a 7.29 ERA and more blown saves – 9 – than regular saves – 8). Ayala would be traded prior to the 1999 season and we would never have to see his punk-ass again. Mike Timlin did an admirable job stepping up and doing what he could, but everyone else from Spoljaric to Slocumb to Bob Wells on down all stunk the joint up. Our five primary bullpen guys went a combined 12-26; take from that what you will. At least no more major trades were made that could blow up in our faces later.
1999 Seattle Mariners
A bit of a lineup shake-up here, with Joey Cora moving on and being replaced by David Bell (second base) who we received for Cora in a 1998 trade deadline deal with the Indians. Bell would never wow you with his bat, but he was a solid infield glove man who would go on in subsequent seasons to lock down third base (and give us all a break from Russ Davis’ stone hands).
Of course, in 1999, Davis was still around. As was Wilson, Segui, A-Rod, Griffey, Buhner, and Martinez. The left field circus continued with Brian Hunter, who we received in trade from the Tigers for a couple of nobodies. Hunter stunk at the plate, but stole 44 bases, so whatever.
The real shakedown happened, of course, with the pitching staff. Freddy Garcia and John Halama, who we received in the Randy Johnson Trade, made their debuts with the organization in 1999. Garcia, in fact, made his Major League debut with the Mariners. Garcia was still a little raw as a rookie, but he was rock solid and would quickly go on to be this team’s ace. Halama was another soft-tossing lefty in the Jamie Moyer mold. He was okay in 1999 and would go on to be no better than okay going forward.
As I mentioned before, Jeff Fassero fell apart this season and was dealt away. Gil Meche rounded out the rotation. He was drafted in the first round in 1996 and immediately made an impression upon his first start that July. Yes, it was a loss, and yes, his numbers weren’t very good. But, he showed a live fastball, a wicked curve, and a whole lotta promise. People were much higher on Meche than they were on Garcia, but either way, this looked like the beginning of a long run of quality starting baseball from our rotation.
The bullpen was re-tooled prior to the 1999 season, with Jose Mesa being signed on as the closer. He would play two seasons in Seattle and would not be missed when he left. Jose Paniagua was signed off of waivers in 1998, where he played in 18 games for the Mariners. He got the bulk of the 8th inning work in 1999 and was a solid, live-arm guy who would never mature into a closer.
These Mariners also suffered through a sub-.500 season, with growing pains in the rotation (Meche, Halama, and Garcia all in their first full seasons) and Fassero completely losing it. There just wasn’t enough pitching to hold together this team with all its hitting prowess.
2000 Seattle Mariners
While the first great Mariners rebuild came to fruition in the 1995 season, the last great Mariners rebuild reached its apex in 2000 and 2001.
The core players from that 1995 team that remained on the 2000 Mariners were: Dan Wilson (catcher), Jay Buhner (right field), and Edgar Martinez (designated hitter). Yes, A-Rod was on that ’95 team, but he was not a regular. There’s been quite a bit of turnover leading us up to what would be the zenith for this franchise in 2000 and 2001.
John Olerud was a longtime veteran who signed prior to the 2000 season to replace David Segui (who replaced Paul Sorrento, who replaced Tino Martinez). Olerud finished his career as a starter in a Mariners uniform, seeing his release in the middle of the 2004 crater of a season. Olerud would finish his career as a part-time player with the Yankees and Red Sox.
Mark McLemore was another longtime veteran who signed prior to the 2000 season to be a utility player. He found a home as a second baseman and caught fire as a super utility player in 2001, bouncing around from left field to third base to wherever else they needed him to play to give others days off. McLemore stuck around through the 2003 season before leaving in free agency to play one final year in Oakland before retiring.
Mike Cameron (center field) was originally drafted by the Chicago White Sox in the 1991 draft. He played in all or parts of four seasons with the White Sox before being traded to the Cincinnati Reds in November of 1998 for Paul Konerko. He started for one season with the Reds before Ken Griffey Jr. demanded to be traded to Cincinnati and only Cincinnati after the 1999 season. In return, the Mariners received Cameron (because they no longer needed a center fielder, thanks to Griffey being there), Brett Tomko, and two other guys. Or, I guess you could say the Mariners received Cameron and three other guys, but that’s neither here nor there.
Mariners fans were a little salty about the whole Griffey thing, especially coming on the heels of the whole Randy Johnson thing (which, if you believe certain reports, is what caused Griffey to sour on the organization in the first place, since the Mariners were not taking care of the veterans who brought them all this success). Mike Cameron helped fans get over Griffey by being a wizard in the field and not a total disaster at the plate. He was actually quite productive in his four years with the Mariners. Cameron left for greener pastures after the 2003 season, signing as a free agent with the Mets, but he will always be accepted as a Mariner for Life thanks to his efforts in Seattle.
The starting rotation featued a combination of six guys. Aaron Sele signed as a free agent before the season and won 17 games. Paul Abbott originally signed as a free agent with the Mariners before the 1997 season. He was primarily a reliever with some spot-start duties. In 2000, he was forced into action and produced admirably. John Halama and Freddy Garcia (again, from the Randy Johnson trade) got their share of starts. Jamie Moyer, the longest-tenured holdover from that trade in 1996, had an injury-plagued 2000 season. And Gil Meche started off the season in the rotation before leaving with a dead arm in early July. He would not pitch again in the Majors until the 2003 season.
Kaz Sasaki signed as a free agent from Japan prior to the season, immediately started closing, and won the Rookie of the Year award. He was the first of back-to-back Japanese Rookies of the Year the Mariners would sign. Sasaki played in four seasons, went to 2 All Star Games, saved 129 games (the franchise leader), and totally fell apart in 2003. He would retire after that season and never played in the Majors again.
Jose Mesa and Jose Paniagua stuck on as middle relievers, but the biggest addition (arguably) was Arthur Rhodes, who signed as a free agent before the season. In his initial tenure with the Mariners, across four seasons, he appeared in 276 games (never fewer than 66 appearances in a season) and had a 3.07 ERA. He was the left-handed reliever we’d been looking for since 1995 and aside from a couple of nasty innings in the 2000 and 2001 American League Championship Series’ against the Yankees, he was arguably the best reliever this team has ever seen.
With that kind of turnover, the Mariners found the mysterious answer to the equation of how to make the playoffs. The core had dwindled from what it was in 1995, but with pieces like Olerud, Cameron, Garcia, Rhodes, Moyer, and Sasaki, they had managed to climb that mountain once again.
2001 Seattle Mariners
In 2001, it would only get better. 116 wins, unheard of in the modern era. There wasn’t a tremendous amount of turnover, but there were two very big names involved that would change the organization forever.
First, there was A-Rod accepting a 10-year, $252 million deal with the Texas Rangers. He would go on to use steroids and become the most hated former Mariner the world has ever known. In his place, the team started Carlos Guillen at short stop, who was another gem in what was a surprisingly decent trade for Randy Johnson. How amazing is it that every piece we got back for Randy in 1998 ended up starting for the Mariners by 2001? I would argue it’s pretty unheard of.
The other big move was signing Ichiro from Japan and making him our everyday right fielder. By this point in his career, Jay Buhner was simply a part-time player and he graciously gave way to the incoming Ichiro, who set the world on fire in his rookie season, winning the ROY as well as the MVP award.
A little more under the radar was the Bret Boone signing. We got him for pennies on the dollar and made him our second baseman. In return, we got a near-MVP season out of him, and a stud second baseman through 2003 before starting his inevitable decline in 2004 and being traded away in the middle of the 2005 season.
Dan Wilson and Edgar Martinez were the only two holdovers from that 1995 team now, with David Bell continuing to man third base, and Mark McLemore platooning with Bell at third and with Al Martin in left field. Al Martin was supposed to be our big deadline deal in July of 2000 to help bolster our outfield hitting. He did no such thing and was a total bust.
Freddy Garcia finally made that next step as the ace of the staff in 2001. Aaron Sele was still oddly productive (in the win/loss department, if not in the actual pitching department) as was Paul Abbott. Jamie Moyer won 20 games to lead the team. Our rotation was rounded out with Halama and Joel Pineiro, who was a 12th round draft pick by the Mariners in 1997. Pineiro would earn full time starting duty in 2002, but would never pan out as we’d hoped.
The bullpen was almost exactly the same as in 2000, except we replaced the dud that was Jose Mesa with the newly signed Jeff Nelson, who was still awesome. Norm Charlton even made a comeback and was somehow good again; I’m telling you, these 2001 Mariners could do no wrong! Until the playoffs, that is.
2002 Seattle Mariners
The 2002 Mariners traded David Bell prior to the season because they had previously traded for the hot-hitting Jeff Cirillo from the Colorado Rockies for Jose Paniagua and others. The hot-hitting Jeff Cirillo never showed up, though. Instead, his nothing-hitting twin brother showed up and sucked my will to live. Cirillo played two mediocre seasons before being dumped on the Padres prior to the 2004 season for batting donuts.
Other than the Cirillo hubbub, the starting lineup was pretty much intact, with McLemore earning the starting left field job.
The rotation took some hits, with Halama and Abbott stinking up the joint, when they managed to stay healthy. Moyer, Garcia, and Pineiro locked down the top three spots, with James Baldwin – a veteran free agent signing – totally crapping the bed. The rest of the starts were spread out over a bunch of different pitchers, no one of note worth mentioning.
Sasaki, Rhodes, and Nelson locked down the best three-man late innings bullpen unit in baseball, with Shigetoshi Hasegawa signing in free agency to make a good bullpen even better (picking up the slack from losing Paniagua).
As I said before, this team would win 93 games, but it actually managed to finish THIRD in the AL West, with Oakland winning 103 games and Anaheim winning 99 and taking the Wild Card. That’s just a crusher any way you slice it; 93 games in most years would be enough to get you there! Not in 2002.
2003 Seattle Mariners
After the 2002 season, Lou Pinella left for another opportunity, this time in Tampa, where he made his offseason home. The Mariners signed on Bob Melvin and tried to keep the train a-rollin’ with most of the same crew attached.
Same infield: Wilson, Olerud, Boone, Guillen, Cirillo. Cammy and Ichiro were still here, along with Edgar Martinez. New addition: Randy Winn (left field) who was traded to us by Tampa. Winn played two and a half years with the Mariners, and they were quality seasons for him, but ultimately he’s a forgotten man for a couple reasons. He came on too late, without a playoff appearance to his name. Also, let’s face it, we were spoiled as Mariners fans. We’d been blessed with this cavalcade of elite power hitters and Winn was anything but. He was a nice piece, but ultimately not enough to push us over the edge into the post-season.
2003 came with it the oddity of having the same five pitchers start all the games that season. Again, we had Jamie Moyer, Freddy Garcia, and Joel Pineiro. Gil Meche returned from the wilderness of Injuryland to grab one of the final spots, with Ryan Franklin bringing up the rear. Franklin was drafted by the Mariners in 1992, but didn’t sign until May of 1993. He had his cup of coffee in 1999, then didn’t return to the Majors until 2001 out of the bullpen. He had a few starts in 2002 and must have shown enough in Spring Training to win a job in 2003, because there he was. Franklin was never what I would call “good” …
For as steady as our starting rotation was, the bullpen was a bit of a mess. Sasaki became way too hittable and lost his closer’s job. Rhodes was losing a bit on his fastball and his ERA suffered for it. Nelson was still rock solid, and Hasegawa was dy-no-mite as the eventual closer replacement. Julio Mateo was a bullpen regular with the Mariners after signing as an amateur free agent back in 1996 as a 19 year old, as was Rafael Soriano (also signed in 1996 as an amateur, though as a 16 year old).
In 2003, the A’s again won the AL West, though they only bested the Mariners by 3 games, winning 96. The Mariners were 2 measly games back of Boston for the Wild Card, so once again they were all dressed up with nowhere to go.
The 2004 Mariners, I think seeing the writing on the wall, tried to reload by signing Raul Ibanez, Scott Spiezio, and Rich Aurilia, but it wouldn’t be enough. Edgar Martinez, Bret Boone, and John Olerud all fell apart. Dan Wilson was getting up there. And the young pitching core of Garcia, Meche, Pineiro, and Franklin just weren’t panning out the way we’d all hoped. The 2004 Mariners bottomed out with 63 wins and it was time to start all over again.
The only piece that would stick long term would be Ichiro, as even Jamie Moyer was traded in the middle of 2006 so he could go to a winner before he retired. It’s been non-stop rebuilding ever since, and nothing thus far has worked for more than a season before falling apart again. The 2013 Mariners are well on their way to a fourth place finish with the current regime led by Jackie Z on very thin ice.
What will the next great Mariners rebuild look like? I haven’t a clue, but I doubt it looks very much like the team we’re watching right now. Here’s to hoping the mojo returns soon, for the sake of my sanity and yours.