Consider this the second in a series of looks back at the 2014 Mariners. For once, it’s going to be more than, “They fucking sucked, I’m sick of thinking about this shit, I’ll see you in February.” I’m sure I’ll toss out the usual “What Went Right” and “What Went Wrong” posts as time and desire permit, but right now I’m taking a look at the players. In short, I’m going to list all the players who accumulated a stat for the 2014 Mariners, and I’m going to talk about each of them individually.
I’m also breaking this up into three parts, because we’re pushing 7,000 words here.
Corey Hart – The Mariners picked him up as a free agent, taking a flyer that he’d return to his old, bashing ways in Milwaukee. Of course, he hadn’t played since 2012 – losing a full year to knee injuries – and baseball isn’t like riding a bike. Especially when you’re
142 years old ABOUT A YEAR YOUNGER THAN I AM? GOOD GOD I’M OLD!
Hart appeared in a lot of games in the first month and a half. Mostly at DH. Occasionally – and ill-advisedly – in the outfield. Then, he was placed on the DL. He returned to play a lot in July, then he went back on the DL again until September call-ups. He stunk throughout, hitting right around .200 for the season.
He had 9 doubles and 6 homers in 68 games. A paltry 32% of his hits went for extra bases, which is not something you’re looking for in a “power hitter” in your cleanup spot, who you want protecting Robinson Cano in the order.
Outlook for 2015: The Mariners have already given him his release, because they needed to make room to bring Jesus Montero back from the suspended list. That’s how little Corey Hart means to this organization, and it’s the perfect representation of his value. When you look back at his career as a Mariner, just think about that and frown. Frown with all your might.
Austin Jackson – If you haven’t by now TL;DR’d this series of posts and you’re following along closely, A-Jax is the second of three guys we traded for in July to help bolster the ballclub. We traded Nick Franklin to get him. Nick Franklin was an expendable trade chip who never really had a future in this organization once Robbie Cano was signed. Austin Jackson was a very good, still-in-his-prime centerfielder with another year of team control in 2015.
The Mariners, of course, DESPERATELY needed a centerfielder. With Guti taking the year off to get his health issues squared away (and no longer a centerfield prospect anymore, given his durability issues), with Abe Almonte a fucking zoo out there, and with James Jones’ absolute dearth of power, we didn’t have a whole lot of options. A-Jax looked like a perfect fit.
In Detroit, from 2010-2013, A-Jax was worth no less than 3.4 wins per year. He was a plus-fielder with quicks on the basepaths who could hit for some pop as well as for average. He declined greatly in 2014, for reasons no one can quite fathom. In Detroit this year, he was average-at-best, though his power and overall hitting numbers weren’t down dramatically. Which makes you wonder if he took that huge step back in the field. Either way, he was better than what we had in Seattle – or so we thought.
In Seattle, A-Jax batted .229/.267/.260. He was good for 0.1 WAR. And, not for nothing, but anecdotally he was a fucking disaster in big situations. Seemed like whenever he had a man on base or otherwise an opportunity to positively affect a ballgame, he would instead ground into a double play or (at best) strike out. He proved to be my least-favorite of the three mid-season acquisitions, and that’s REALLY saying something Kendrys Morales.
Outlook for 2015: Still in Seattle, still starting in center, still batting leadoff. At least out of Spring Training. Beyond that, who’s to say? If he plays like he did in the last two months of this season, you never know. We may be talking about one of the many reasons why the 2015 Mariners DON’T make the playoffs. Honestly, we’re REALLY counting on A-Jax to turn it around. I highly doubt the Mariners are going to go out and find another guy to compete in center. So, if A-Jax fails, and there’s no one in the minors to take his place, we’re proper fucked at a spot on the team where we’re banking on being set. Just in case you were overwhelmed by the warm-fuzzies after this pleasant 2014 run, keep that in mind.
James Jones – In his first two months, James Jones was amazing. He was everything Abe Almonte wasn’t. He was crisp at the plate. He wasn’t the most-refined in the outfield, but he was solid enough. And, he was a wizard on the basepaths.
Then, July came around and he started falling off. We all started noticing his faults. Like: how he wasn’t really improving as a centerfielder. Like: how he couldn’t hit for power. Like: how if he didn’t slap a single the other way, he couldn’t get on base to take advantage of those legs. In the end, he lost his starting job, was sent back to Tacoma for a couple weeks, then returned exclusively as a bench player.
Keep him away from the starting lineup, keep him out of center, and watch him shine. He’s a plus-defender in the corner outfield, with speed and a strong arm. Put him in during the later innings to replace Endy Chavez or whoever. Pinch run him for Kendrys Morales or some other slow piece of crap. He’s GOLD!
27 stolen bases in 28 attempts. Very, very good.
14 extra-base hits in 312 at-bats (with only 12 walks vs. 67 strikeouts) is very, very BAD. That’s factoring in how a lot of those doubles were hustle-doubles.
Outlook for 2015: He needs to bulk up. He needs to get a little more power into his bat. He needs to retain how well he hit the outside pitch the other way, but he’s also gotta recognize pitches better and take MANY more walks. His career will be built on a foundation of base-stealing. If he wants that career to primarily take place in the Majors, then he needs to figure out a way to get on base with more regularity. In an ideal world, he’d fix what’s wrong with him and be our fourth or fifth outfielder. But, I got a feeling he’ll start out in Tacoma again. Not the worst thing in the world.
Brad Miller – In following the Dustin Ackley Path To Success, Brad Miller was a mid-season call-up as a rookie and did quite well. So well, in fact, that he pretty much earned his starting job without a fight. Nevertheless, the Mariners put the short stop job up for grabs between Miller and Nick Franklin. Didn’t matter, as Miller mopped the floor with him in the month of March. The job was his, and everyone rejoiced.
Then the regular season started:
- April: .173/.212/.333 with 26 strikeouts in 81 at-bats
- May: .136/.260/.152 with 17 strikeouts and 1 extra-base hit in 66 at-bats
In June, he turned it around with: .298/.355/.512 with 21 strikeouts in 84 at-bats. But, then July happened: .172/.262/.224 with 12 strikeouts and 3 extra-base hits in 58 at-bats. On July 24th, Miller lost his starting job for good, with the promotion of Chris Taylor. From that point on, they’d split duties, with Taylor getting the bulk of the looks the rest of the way in high-pressure games.
To his credit, Miller did turn his season around somewhat:
- August: .273/.357/.545 with 6 strikeouts and 4 extra-base hits in only 22 at-bats
- September: .314/.340/.549 with 13 strikeouts and 7 extra-base hits in 51 at-bats
On the whole, Miller’s 2014 was worse than his 2013, but he still has the potential to be a solid starting short stop in this league. His power potential is undeniable. His defense isn’t quite as good as Taylor’s, but he’s very athletic and there’s talk of him maybe converting to outfield (or, at least adding that to his repertoire to become a super-utility guy). Normally, losing your starting position and getting that super-utility label is a death sentence, but in this case I’m willing to hear it out.
Outlook for 2015: He will once again come in competing for the starting short stop job, this time against Chris Taylor. If he mashes again like he did in Spring of 2014, he’s certain to win the job out of camp. But, I have no doubt that if all things are equal with health, there will be a short leash on Miller if he struggles again in April.
Jesus Montero – You know the story: we traded Michael Pineda and some other dude for Montero and Hector Noesi. Noesi was a disaster who was finally DFA’d this year (and who became an okay starter for a struggling White Sox team). Pineda has been mostly injured throughout his time with the Yankees, but at season’s end he flashed that potential he showed in Seattle as a rookie.
Jesus Montero, on the other hand, has been a fucking loser from the get-go. First, he was our starting catcher of the future; that didn’t pan out. Then, we looked to convert him to first base; that hasn’t gone well. He’s a fat, immobile turd who gets to add “injury prone” to his list of descriptors. Then, towards the end of the 2014 season, on a rehab assignment with the Everett Aqua Sox, functioning as a first base coach (which, not for nothing, is his future in the game: a base coach for a single-A baseball team), Jesus Montero was baited into an altercation with an allegedly drunken scout (at the time) for the Seattle Mariners after that scout (again allegedly) sent him an ice cream sandwich and yelled at him to hustle more.
The scout was fired (and rightly so, because I like to give Montero shit, but even I know he was acting like a cunt), and Jesus Montero was suspended (probably because he went into the stands with a baseball bat in his hands, which is a huge no-no in sports). Montero has since been reinstated, and is apparently being watched like a hawk by the Mariners’ front office. There’s one last chance on the table for Montero in a Mariners uniform (or, more likely, for Montero as trade bait to try to recoup some of his tons of lost value). They’ve got him in Arizona working out on a strict exercise program (because, you know, he came in fat to Spring Training 2014 and admitted as such in interviews that all he did was sit around and stuff his face during the offseason).
Outlook for 2015: Once a loser, always a loser. There will be all this crap written about how he’s in the “best shape of his life”, but that’ll probably mean that he’s lost all his power. He’ll start out in Tacoma and continue to suck (if he’s not outright traded in the offseason as a throw-in to a much bigger deal).
Kendrys Morales – Sigh. Here we go.
You remember him as a productive hitter for the Angels for a bunch of years. Then, he broke his foot or some damn thing while celebrating a game-winning home run and he ended up losing his 2011 season. The Mariners swapped Jason Vargas for him straight up prior to the 2013 season (after a decent, but not great 2012) and he had a decent, but not great first year with the club.
The big draw with Morales – aside from being a huge step up compared to the other DHs we’ve employed since Edgar Martinez retired – was that even though he’d be a free agent at season’s end, we could tender him and if he signed as a free agent elsewhere, we’d get a high draft pick (a first rounder most likely, unless it was one of the top 10 “protected” draft picks). So, we offered him the tender – 1 year, $14.1 million – and of course he turned it down. Reportedly, we even offered him a 3-year, $30 million deal, and he turned THAT down. See, Scott Boras is his agent, and together they thought they could squeeze a little more out of the free agent market.
They couldn’t. No one would sign him. Because no one wants a broken down statue on the basepaths who can’t play first base because he’ll get hurt or need a few days off every time. He’s a DH and nothing more, and not even that great of a DH at that. .449 slugging percentage in 2013, playing almost every single day. That’s crap. When you bring nothing else to the table, then guess what: you don’t get contract offers when it means a team has to give up a high draft pick.
In June, he signed with the Twins. Again reportedly, the Mariners were interested in signing him during the season, but he wouldn’t have it. So, we ended up trading for him, by giving the Twins Stephen Pryor (a reliever returning from major injury who was no longer the smoke-thrower he was pre-surgery).
Kendrys had 154 at bats with the Twins. His numbers were bad (.234/.259/.325), but we all rationalized it away by saying, “He didn’t have a REAL Spring Training, so just consider his numbers with the Twins as his Spring.”
That oft-belabored talking point would soon switch to, “If the Mariners can just get Kendrys going down the stretch, everything should be all right with the offense.” That’s because he was much, MUCH worse as a Seattle Mariner than he was as a Twin (hitting .207/.285/.347), so whenever he managed to do something right (which, again, wasn’t very often), we all had to hope and pray that THIS was the day that turned a slumping slugger who has “always hit” into what we thought we were getting as the centerpiece of our mid-season trades to bolster a contending team.
Alas, it wasn’t meant to be. But, at least Morales doesn’t have to worry about being tendered anymore. Even if he DID qualify, there’s no way in FUCKING HELL that even the Mariners would be stupid enough to offer him a 1-year deal for $15.3 million.
Outlook for 2015: If he had managed even a semi-reasonable finish to his 2014 season, I could’ve seen the Mariners trying to bring him back on a 2-3 year deal. But, he looked so bad, I doubt it’d happen. On top of that, I don’t think Morales wants to be here. Truth be told, he never did (and proved it by signing with a last-place Twins team even though the Mariners were in contention this year and wanted him back), but after his disaster of a season, I think he’s going somewhere on a prove-it deal. Some place like Baltimore or the Yankees or some other place he can DH in a small ballpark. Get his numbers back up to where they should be, and then hopefully sign a final long-term deal for big money with the Rangers or some damn place.