I don’t think we’re going to see a lot of national coverage on what the Seahawks did in this draft, and I’m okay with that. You can see it as disrespect all you want, and I’m okay with that too, but that just means we can sit here in our little corner of the United States and just focus on football. We’re not one of these teams who needed to draft a quarterback in the top third of the first round; we didn’t select any of these woman-beaters or drug users. Hell, most of our guys have really uplifting and tearjerking stories of how they got to where they are today! Good character guys, who at the very least won’t distract us from what’s most important: the quality of play on the field. I can’t tell you how sick and tired I was of all the Frank Clark stuff when we brought him in a couple years ago. I thank my lucky stars we didn’t get Joe Mixon, or some of these other guys, so I don’t have to read 5,000 thinkpieces on why the NFL hates women (they do, or at least they don’t give a shit about women, so long as you can score touchdowns or sack quarterbacks on the reg, but it doesn’t mean I want to spend the whole offseason reading about it over and over again).
I know I don’t know much about the players the Seahawks drafted, so I can’t really give an informed opinion. I like the thought process behind the positions the Seahawks targeted, even if it’s not necessarily the order I would’ve picked them in (I’ll have a separate post written at some point, lamenting the lack of Huskies and further lamenting where most of them ended up).
As always, it’s going to take a few years to see where we’re at with this class, so I’ll forego grading this thing:
- 2nd Round – Malik McDowell – DT/DE
- 2nd Round – Ethan Pocic – OL
- 3rd Round – Shaquill Griffin – CB
- 3rd Round – Delano Hill – SS
- 3rd Round – Nazair Jones – DT
- 3rd Round – Amara Darboh – WR
- 4th Round – Tedric Thompson – FS
- 6th Round – Mike Tyson – S/CB
- 6th Round – Justin Senior – OT/G
- 7th Round – David Moore – WR
- 7th Round – Christopher Carson – RB
After trading down twice – from 26 to 31 (to get an extra 3rd & 7th), then from 31 to 34 (to get a 4th rounder) – the Seahawks traded down from 34 to 35 with Jacksonville, picking up an extra 6th rounder.
With the 35th pick, the Seahawks finally selected Malik McDowell. This guy will play right away, particularly in obvious passing situations, as a pass rushing defensive tackle. He can also play on the end, as I’m sure he and Michael Bennett will be interchangeable. From the tape I watched on him after we made this pick, he looks like he can be quite the disruptive force in getting upfield. I don’t know if he’s too great at stopping the run, so that might be something for him to work on. He’ll need to stay extremely disciplined if he plays for the Seahawks, minding the gaps he’s supposed to mind and so on. There’s also people who greatly question his effort, which is obviously concerning, because I keep hearing reports that McDowell is a Top 5 talent if not for his effort concerns. I have to wonder if that just means going all out every play, or if that encompasses his entire life. Like, is he going to keep up with offseason workout programs? Am I going to have to worry about him showing up overweight and out of shape?
What I don’t buy is McDowell falling because of poor interviews. I don’t care if my stud D-Linemen are great orators; quite frankly, with guys like Bennett, Sherman, Doug Baldwin, and so on and so forth on this team, I wouldn’t mind the Seahawks drafting a fucking mute. Who cares if McDowell gives boring, one-word answers? He’s not getting paid to give great interviews; he’s getting paid to kill the quarterback!
What I also don’t buy is knocking McDowell for poor effort on a bad Michigan State team in his senior season. They keep saying his effort went downhill as they kept losing as the season wore on. Well, so what? If I only have to worry about his effort when he’s on a bad team, then I shouldn’t have to worry very much, because the Seahawks are VERY good still! He’s coming onto a championship contender, so I would expect the effort will be there. And, if it’s not, or if he’s injury prone or whatever, then we obviously have huge problems.
What I saw when I watched McDowell play is a guy with long arms, lots of strength, and lots of quickness. He’s going to make quick work of single-teams, and if he’s double-teamed (which he probably should be a lot of the time, particularly on the interior of the line), then that just opens up lanes for Bennett, Avril, Clark, and so on. The upside with this kid is through the roof! If the veterans are able to keep him in line and he comes in with a positive attitude, we could be looking at the guy who replaces Bennett whenever he’s ready to retire. McDowell is a potential superstar and long-term player, if we got this pick right. If we failed, and he turns out to be a diva, he could be a spectacular bust.
One of the biggest shocks for me of this Seahawks draft is – after they made all of their trade downs to collect extra draft picks – they didn’t try to trade up (particularly in the 2nd round) and use some of that extra draft capital to pick up a unique talent. Maybe the right deal never came along, maybe the unique talent didn’t fall far enough, or maybe all the talent at the end of the 2nd round was pretty much the same anyway and the Seahawks just took the best player available (considering their needs, of course).
In this case, that player turned out to be Ethan Pocic, offensive lineman out of LSU. He checks off a lot of the boxes we like: pro-style offense, has played multple positions along the line, is very intelligent, is very athletic, played in the SEC, and he absolutely towers over Russell Wilson, so watch out for those sight lines!
I think what flipped out a lot of Seahawks fans about this one is the fact that he primarily played center for LSU. He does have experience at tackle and guard, but the overwhelming majority of his playing time was devoted to center. And, obviously, the Seahawks already have their starting center in Britt. Which means either we picked this guy to be our center after 2017 (in this case, Britt would walk in free agency), or the Seahawks plan to eventually extend Britt long term, and we’ve just drafted yet another guy we’re going to have to convert into something else. Something that’s NOT his natural center position. It’s just getting a little frustrating, you know? Carpenter came in as a right tackle, eventually converted to left guard. Britt was a right tackle, then a guard, until he finally made it work at center. Ifedi was supposed to be a right tackle, but last year we made him a right guard, and now it looks like we’re going to move him back to tackle again? Now, this Pocic guy, who is a center, will be a WHAT in 2017?
Well, for now, it looks like he’ll land on the right side of the line. He, Ifedi, and Aboushi will all compete to be starters for those two positions, with the loser as backup. I’ll talk more about my thoughts on the O-Line another time, but for now, I like the pick. I’ll like Pocic even more if he IS as versatile as they say he’ll be.
The next two guys were right in my sweet spot. Right where I’ve been screaming at the Seahawks to address since the 2016 season ended: the secondary.
Shaquill Griffin is a cornerback out of UCF. 6′, 194 lbs. He’s got long arms, is apparently a good tackler, and can play press coverage or off the ball, so he’s exactly what the Seahawks look for in a corner. He should come in and compete for a starting spot right away, and can likely play inside or outside, which is nice, because the Seahawks need both.
Delano Hill is a strong safety out of Michigan. Nearly 6’1, 216 lbs. He strikes me as a Kam Chancellor type. He likely starts out as a backup safety, playing a lot of special teams, and learning at the feet of the master. He is good in helping to stop the run, but his coverage skills may be suspect. Of course, they said the same thing about Kam when he came out in the draft, so we’ll just have to see. If he can spend the majority of this year just being a promising backup, maybe next year he’ll come in and be twice the player he is now.
With the final two picks in the third round, the Seahawks did some very Seahawky things.
First up, Nazair Jones, DT out of North Carolina. 6’5, 304 lbs. This guy is more of a run-stuffer, likely replacing Tony McDaniel in the interior rotation on base defense. He should fit in nicely with Reed and Rubin, though you’ll be hard pressed to see him and McDowell on the field at the same time. They kind of project to play the same spot on the line, with Jones in there on likely run situations, and McDowell there in likely passing situations. This pick would seem to eliminate the annual last-minute DT free agent signing, and hopefully shore this position up for a few years.
Then, the Seahawks went rogue, picking up Amara Darboh, wide receiver out of Michigan. 6’2, 214 lbs. Big receiver who likely won’t play much right away (unless he catches on as a special teamer), he does project to have a potentially huge role in 2018 and beyond. We’re going into a contract year with Paul Richardson, and we’re also going into the likely final year with Jermaine Kearse (as you can cut him after the 2017 season with minimal dead money going against the cap). While Darboh doesn’t have the speed of a Richardson, he could very well have the ball skills and leaping ability to high point over defenders. And, while Darboh doesn’t have the experience or toughness of a Kearse, he does appear to have the blocking ability that’s kept Kearse employed for so long. The question remains: can he make those big, game-changing catches we’ve seen Kearse come down with throughout the years? He’ll have to prove that in practice and pre-season games.
That having been said, I have the same concerns for him as I do for all mid-round receivers: will he ever develop into anything? A guy like Doug Baldwin can flourish when he came into the league, because the Seahawks were still rebuilding when he signed on. But, the Seahawks are mostly set everywhere and are just filling in the cracks of the back-end of the roster. Can Darboh make an immediate impact? If not, can the Seahawks afford to keep a guy based on potential? When our championship window continues to close on us? It just seems like these “big” receivers we keep drafting are never worth a shit. Hopefully, Darboh is the exception and not the rule.
After a pleasant night to think about the final four rounds, the Seahawks were back at it early on Saturday. They had the 3rd pick of the 4th round, then didn’t pick again until the 3rd pick of the 6th round, but that didn’t stop them from bolstering their secondary with both of those selections.
Tedric Thompson, a safety out of Colorado, kicked it off. 6′, 204 lbs. While Delano Hill projects as more of a Kam-type safety, Thompson projects as more of an Earl-type free safety. Generally speaking, Colorado’s secondary was the best secondary the Huskies played all year last year; those guys REALLY impressed the shit out of me, and it obviously translated into those guys getting drafted by the NFL. Thompson has great coverage and ball skills, producing a lot of turnovers in college, which is exactly what the Seahawks need. His tackling skills leave a lot to be desired, but I feel like that’s something the Seahawks can coach into him. The real worry is his history of concussions. With the way this team likes to tackle – emphasizing shoulder tackling over spearing guys and drawing flags – I wouldn’t think that would be a huge problem. But, you can never REALLY prevent hits to the head, so it’s going to require a bit of luck to keep Thompson in the league over a long career.
Then, the Seahawks picked up Mike Tyson out of Cincinnati in the 6th round, and everyone had a huge fucking laugh. 6’1, 204 lbs. He’s very athletic and very raw. Right now, he’s projected to compete as a cornerback as well as safety, so we could be looking at a guy to help compete at the nickel. I would anticipate he cracks the special teams, develops behind the scenes, and maybe starts getting rotated into the nickel defense in 2018 and beyond (that is, if he makes the team at all, which is far from a guarantee).
More than anything, I love the strategy here. The Seahawks saw a need for depth in the secondary, and instead of just drafting a couple 3rd rounders and calling it a day, they went out and threw a bunch of resources into the L.O.B. All four of these guys won’t make the Opening Day roster, but you seriously improve your chances of hitting on at least one or two of these guys with the more picks you devote to the position. I think that, more than anything, is the reason why the Seahawks never used their extra picks to move back up in any one round. They wanted this to be a Numbers Game situation. You hit on 100 women at the bar, odds are you’ll get at least 1 phone number!
The Seahawks had 3 picks in the late 6th and 7th rounds. All of these guys are projects who I won’t spend much time on.
In the 6th, the Seahawks picked up Justin Senior, offensive tackle out of Mississippi State. 6’5, 331 lbs. He’s only played right tackle, so that would appear to be his spot. That having been said, a guy just playing one position has never prevented the Seahawks from pounding a square peg into a round hole. Even if that position is power forward on the college basketball team, but I digress. I wouldn’t expect much out of this kid. Best case scenario is he’s a backup swing tackle. Again, more depth.
In the early 7th, the Seahawks selected David Moore, wide receiver out of East Central. 6’1, 219 lbs. He’s from a Division II school, which isn’t a reason to keep him out of the NFL, but obviously you first have to question the level of talent he played against. His only shot to make the team is if he plays special teams REALLY well. Odds are, we try to stash him on the practice squad.
In the late 7th, the Seahawks brought in Christopher Carson, running back out of OK State. 6′, 218 lbs. Another long shot, though with the way Seahawks running backs have been getting injured the last couple seasons, maybe not as long a shot as it would first appear? He kind of strikes me as a Thomas Rawls type, so maybe he’s a hedge against yet another Rawls injury.
All in all, I don’t mind the strategy. I will say this: I think the odds of the Seahawks picking up a cornerback who can start right away were MUCH better when taking one with your first pick, as opposed to your third rounder. They obviously felt that the drop-off from McDowell and the type of pass-rushing DT that would’ve been available to them later in the draft was too much to cope with, when compared to the lesser drop-off of cornerbacks from Kevin King to Shaq Griffin. But, when I look at a Kevin King (or other, comparable cornerbacks in the late first/early second round), I see a guy who not only starts right away, but plays every down. When I look at a guy like McDowell, I see a guy who plays situationally, in a rotation. Now, the ceiling on McDowell is through the roof, so maybe you take the long-term approach to your draft assessment. If you hit on McDowell, and he plays at a Pro Bowl level, you can argue a disruptive D-line force is more valuable than a starting cornerback in a Cover Three defense. But, I also think the odds of McDowell becoming that Pro Bowl-type player are longer than they are for someone like Kevin King to be a Pro Bowl corner. In which case, the Seahawks might’ve forsaken a Pro Bowl corner just to draft a Cassius Marsh-type D-lineman (worst case scenario, obviously).
But, you can’t say the Seahawks are afraid to take risks. Go big or go home seems to be the motto. I think this draft, more than any of the drafts since 2013, is the most pivotal to our long-term success. In that sense, if they’ve failed this weekend, and passed on more sure things to roll the dice on the likes of McDowell, Pocic, and Griffin, it could really spell doom for this franchise and set us back a long time. I mean, look at the results, we haven’t had a game-changing draft since 2012; it’s been spotty at best ever since. We need to get back to really hitting on some guys, or this team is going to wither and die at the feet of an aging Russell Wilson in a few years.
If nothing else, though, I like the potential of this draft to do EXACTLY what it was supposed to do: improve the depth of this ballclub at the back-end of the roster. The secondary looks like it could be replenished in a big way, the D-line DEFINITELY looks like it’s got some dogs for many years to come, the team didn’t neglect the all-important offensive line (as Pocic looks like he can not only come in to play right away, but he might be the best lineman after Britt on the entire team, without playing a single snap!), and they looked to the future of the wide receiver position and brought in at least one very interesting player who could be productive in 2018 and beyond.
If some of these guys can come in to play right away, it’ll be huge. You know injuries are coming, and you know some of these guys (particularly on defense) will be pressed into action early and maybe often. If they can do what some of our crappier reserves from last year couldn’t – and actually mitigate the drop-off in quality of play from starter to backup – the Seahawks might just have another Super Bowl run in them.
That’s a very big IF, of course, but the draft is here to give us hope, so we might as well take a long, satisfying drag from that cigarette.