Consider this the third in a series of looks back at the 2014 Mariners. For once, it’s going to be more than, “They fucking sucked, I’m sick of thinking about this shit, I’ll see you in February.” I’m sure I’ll toss out the usual “What Went Right” and “What Went Wrong” posts as time and desire permit, but right now I’m taking a look at the players. In short, I’m going to list all the players who accumulated a stat for the 2014 Mariners, and I’m going to talk about each of them individually.
I’m also breaking this up into three parts, because we’re pushing 7,000 words here.
Logan Morrison – Following the signing of Corey Hart, the Mariners hedged their bet by trading away Carter Capps to the Marlins for their version of Justin Smoak. LoMo played a little more outfield than Smoak ever could have dreamed, and he was a lot more injured, but the sentiment is still the same: a guy with a lot of power potential who just never put it together, for a maddeningly long amount of time.
He’s yet to play a full season (only over 100 games once in his 5-year Major League career), and he’s yet to be all that effective at the plate. Encouragingly, 2014 was his best year ever, so there’s hope yet.
He hit .262/.315/.420, with 11 homers and 20 doubles in 99 games. He had only 9 games in the outfield, with the rest at 1B or DH, which is promising. Let’s keep him there. He was a VAST improvement over Justin Smoak (who got the lion’s share of starts early in the season at first base) offensively, and wasn’t all that bad defensively either. He’s club-controlled and if he can stay healthy, might just be a viable starting first baseman for us. He’s no All Star or anything, but at this point I’ll just take anyone who’s above replacement.
Outlook for 2015: Slot him in as your starting first baseman. At best, the Mariners will only be able to bring in one right-handed slugger, and you have to figure that guy will play primarily at DH. If, in some incomprehensible universe, the Mariners bring in two sluggers, then I suppose you could be looking at LoMo as a platoon option at first/DH. But, I bet he sticks and makes us all forget about that time he smashed a bat against a wall in frustration and cut up his face, causing him to miss some time.
Humberto Quintero – Says here he was a third catcher down the stretch and had as many at-bats (2) as Felix Hernandez (as many hits too).
Outlook for 2015: He’s a free agent. Either he’ll be back in Tacoma, or he’ll be with some other team’s AAA squad, or he’ll be somewhere else.
Stefen Romero – As per usual, the Mariners were desperate for right-handed outfield bats. Stefen Romero was pretty good in Spring Training and won a spot on the Major League club. He stunk. He was sent down and brought up multiple times. In that aforementioned game in Atlanta where John Buck hit the game-winning home run, Romero hit a game-tying 3-run home run that ultimately led to Buck’s magic. This day would be the highlight for both of these men in 2014.
Outlook for 2015: I dunno. Tacoma probably. Outside shot at a bench spot with the Mariners, but I wouldn’t count on it.
Michael Saunders – I’m just going to come out and say it: Michael Saunders was the third best position player on the Mariners in 2014 behind Cano and Seager. That’s really saying something, considering he only appeared in 78 games.
Why did he only appear in 78 games? Well, to start the season, he was on the bench, behind Almonte, LoMo, Romero, and others. When he got a chance to play – however infrequently – he consistently produced. But, he missed a huge chunk of June with an injury; then again missed some of July, all of August, and some more of September with another injury.
Is this what the team considers Michael Saunders to be? This injury-prone fourth outfielder who needs regular days off to stay healthy, fresh, and productive? Probably. Not for nothing, but when you’re talking about these guys who play all-out all the time, I tend to agree. Yeah, he’ll give up his body to make a play, but he’ll be paying for it later. That’s why I never understood all the vitriol with Ichiro never diving. Do you want him falling all over the field going after balls? Or, do you want a guy you can count on to be in your lineup every single day? Same thing with Shaun Alexander. Until the end of his career, he was very durable. Why? He went down and out of bounds rather than take unnecessary hits. I love Beastmode and Jay Buhner as much as the next guy, but I’m just sayin’, there’s nothing wrong with taking care of yourself and living to fight another day.
Outlook for 2015: He’s looking to get a raise in arbitration. He should certainly be back. Pencil him in as a fourth outfielder with a chance to win a starting job if things break right. If you wanted my prediction right now, though, I’d say he’s not starting. I’ve got Ackley in left, A-Jax in center, and Free Agent X or Trade Acquisition Y in right. Still, it’ll be nice to have Saunders back, as I DO think he’s a bona fide Major Leaguer. He’ll be even more valuable if we manage to find three viable starters to play ahead of him in the outfield. No more crappy Endy Chavez for us if we can help it!
Kyle Seager – LOVE me some Kyle Seager, boy! Hot damn that kid is damn hot!
He led the team in homers with 25 and RBI with 96. He made his very first All Star game and got a couple flimsy hacks in. He’s been a regular since July 2011 (the same time as Ackley) and he hasn’t let us down once! In his three full seasons, he’s hit at least 20 homers and batted between .259 and .268. All the while, improving dramatically with his defense at third base. This is reflected in his WAR, which has gone up from 2.6 in 2012, to 3.9 in 2013, to a whopping 5.8 this year. He was only bested in that number by Felix and Cano, which puts him in rarefied air.
And the best part? He can still get better! Particularly at the plate. I agree with LMC, he can and SHOULD be hitting in the .280s. And, if this team manages to produce some heavy hitters in this lineup, I think he’d be an ideal 2-hole hitter. Regardless, I have no problem with him batting fifth, IF we find a legitimate cleanup guy.
Either way, I love the fact that there’s someone besides Cano and Felix who I don’t have to worry about. He doesn’t slump for extended periods of time. He’s not afraid to hit in Safeco. He doesn’t get injured. He doesn’t have extreme splits at the plate. Thank God for Kyle Seager!
Outlook for 2015: I’ll have what I’m having!
Justin Smoak – Ahh, the anti-Seager. Before the season – indeed, even before Spring Training – Smoak was touted as the starting first baseman. He was someone LMC declared would one day lead the league in doubles. Instead, he’s successfully led the league in facepalm moments.
His April was no good after his first seven games. His May was even worse. In June, he was either sent down to Tacoma or injured. Either way, he sucked dick the rest of the way. .202/.275/.339. THIRTEEN doubles. PRETTY sure that’s not even close to league-leading.
Outlook for 2015: He’s arbitration-eligible and due to make some serious coin if he stays. He’s also out of minor league options, so we can’t just stash him in Tacoma when we’re sick and tired of looking at him. I have to believe, with every fiber of my being, that he won’t be back. He’s been given every chance in the world to succeed and he’s been dreadful at every turn. It’s time for him to go elsewhere and fail miserably for someone else. If he’s lucky, the Rockies will sign him and he’ll parlay a hot Spring Training into an okay career, making us all wonder, “What If”, except I’ll tell you What If: he never would’ve made it in Seattle! It’s Bandbox or Bust for Smoak.
Jesus Sucre – This was the guy we brought up to replace John Buck. He’s a better receiver of baseballs – he can frame a pitch well and has a pretty good arm – but he’s nothing with a bat in his hands.
Outlook for 2015: I’m almost certain he’ll be back in Tacoma. There’s an outside chance he’s back up here as a backup to Zunino. But, I have to believe that “backup catcher” is once again one of our middling priorities in the upcoming offseason.
Chris Taylor – He was called up and played his first game on July 24th. He would’ve been called up sooner, but he had to go on the DL for a brief period. Either way, his promotion was made possible by Brad Miller being a suck-ass for the first few months of the season.
In total, he played in 47 games. He had a great batting average (.287), but only hit 8 balls for extra bases (with no triples or homers). His defense was a step above Miller’s, so there’s your trade off. Miller is a guy who will hit for power, but he won’t walk, so if he’s not striking the ball flush, then he’s not doing much for you. Taylor is a guy who will never hit for power, but he walks a little more and doesn’t strike out NEARLY as much. He also gives you better defense.
Or, put it this way: Taylor was worth 1.5 WAR in his 47 games; Miller was worth 1.6 WAR in 123 games.
So, what do you value? Premium power at a premium position? Or defense and stability? If Miller plays up to his potential (meaning: hitting for a high average and cutting down somewhat on strikeouts, while maintaining his power), then his ceiling is one of the best offensive short stops in baseball. I think Taylor is pretty much at his ceiling right now, meaning he’s anywhere from a 3.5 to 4.5-WAR player (if he can keep it up through a full season).
Outlook for 2015: I guess we’ll find out next year. It’ll be interesting to see the short stop position battle shake out in Spring Training, and it’ll be even more interesting to see if the winner of that battle can hold onto his job. Gun to my head: I think Miller has the edge in this race. I think they love his power and are willing to put up with some defensive lapses and slumps. Not TOO MANY slumps, mind you, but I guess we’ll see. Taylor is a nice Plan B to have.
Mike Zunino – Right out of the gate, just know that Mike Zunino isnt going anywhere. He’s the entrenched starter as catcher and will be for years to come.
With that out of the way … KIND OF a woofer of a 2014. Here are the positives:
- He stayed healthy and played in 131 of a possible 162 games. That’s quite a workload!
- He threw out 28.3% of base stealers (28 of 99), which I want to say is good (at least, it’s a vast improvement over the duds we’ve had here since Dan Wilson retired).
- He was in the upper echelon of pitch-framers, stealing more would-be balls as strikes than most other catchers in baseball.
- His Catcher E.R.A. was 3.18 (I don’t even know what that means, or if it’s even a good stat or not)
- He only had 8 passed balls all year (considering he catches Felix on a regular basis, VERY impressive).
- He hit 22 home runs.
- He’s only 23 years old and already has a year and a half of Major League experience under his belt.
You notice that most of his positives are defense-related, yet I’m seeing here that his Defensive-WAR was only 0.3 and his overall WAR was only 0.6. According to other metrics, he actually had NEGATIVE defensive runs saved numbers. What the shit?
I was all prepared to come on here and talk about what a stud he’s been defensively, and about what a black hole he’s been at the plate. Turns out, not so fast.
With my untrained eye (and mediocre grasp of advanced stats), I think he’s still good defensively. I know for a FACT that he’s the best catcher we’ve had in YEARS. Again, probably since Wilson. I also think that his bat stinks, but it’s sure to get better. It would almost have to, as I don’t think it can get much worse.
He had 476 plate appearances in 2014. Of those, 337 were against right-handed pitchers and 139 were against lefties. Here are his splits:
- Vs. Lefties: .252/.295/.427, 8 doubles, 5 homers, 42 strikeouts, 30.2% Ks
- Vs. Righties: .176/.237/.394, 12 doubles, 2 triples, 17 homers, 116 strikeouts, 34.4% Ks
That’s gotta tighten up. He’s a home run blast waiting to happen, but much more often he’s a strikeout waiting to happen. And against righties, he’s remarkably worse. That’s gotta change, because we can’t just save him for lefties. We’ve got to hit on this guy because he’s THAT important to our future.
Outlook for 2015: Starting catcher. You probably want to keep him towards the bottom of the lineup again. Which isn’t the worst thing in the world. Let him get his feet wet and maybe one day he’ll be a 5-hole or 6-hole hitter. I’m not too worried yet, but his offense has to pick up. If he hits in 2015 the way he did in 2014, I’m going to be VERY concerned.